File Size: 7447 KB
Print Length: 446 pages
Publisher: University of Chicago Press; Reprint edition (September 15, 2008)
Publication Date: September 15, 2008
Sold by: Digital Services LLC
X-Ray: Not Enabled
Word Wise: Not Enabled
Lending: Not Enabled
Enhanced Typesetting: Not Enabled
Best Sellers Rank: #864,235 Paid in Kindle Store (See Top 100 Paid in Kindle Store) #10 in Kindle Store > Kindle eBooks > Crafts, Hobbies & Home > Gardening & Horticulture > Flowers > Bulbs #65 in Books > Crafts, Hobbies & Home > Gardening & Landscape Design > Flowers > Bulbs #233 in Books > History > Europe > Netherlands
After reading Tulipmania, I feel that the book could have been better than it was. Goldgar claims that she used firsthand sources that no one else has used to study the topic of Tulipmania before, allowing her to draw conclusions that no one has previously done. Essentially, Goldgar questions the traditional interpretation throughout history of Tulipmania, particularly the effect that the crisis actually had on Dutch society.Even though these new sources shed new light on the topic, I felt that the book could have been delivered in a much better way. Goldgar quickly becomes bogged down with the minutia of the tulip trade. She did talk about overall trends; however, I think the book would have been much more interesting if she didn't spend as much time writing about individual transactions or individual meetings between buyers and sellers. These are necessary to establish the validity of the argument, but I think that the book would be more enjoyable with a few less of these examples.The book also could have been improved with some overall statistics about Dutch society at the time. For example, (without giving too much away) claims about the economic conditions in the Netherlands during the early 17th century could have been backed up with more than just assertions from the author. In addition, the book does not spend a lot of time on some key issues, particularly, why the prices suddenly collapsed. This may have been out of the scope of the book, and the author does state that the issue is extremely complex and has no easy answer. But I think it would have added to the book to spend a bit more time discussing a few of the possible reasons.This is not to say that the book had no positives.
Is Tulipmania a good book, I was left wondering after having finished it. I guess to ask this question is to answer it. Still, by researching the tulip trade in the Dutch Golden Age, Anne Goldgar hit on archival gold. A massive amount of previously ill researched primary source material is combined with an impressive body of secundary literature. She combines insights from both historians and art historians. And with this wealth of material, Goldgar tells a concise and insightful story. As a nice topping, on every other page or so the book displays plates an illustrations from the period.But very often, one is left slightly baffled by Goldgar's train of thought. One is more or less ready to follow Goldgar when she argues that well-to-do Dutchmen liked to have collections tulips and shells because both could be linked to the (apparently) highly-esteemed marble. Of course, there is no way of knowing whether this was true, but the connection is interesting. When from there on, she starts a discussion on the Â« soul-like Â» qualities of pets and tulips in paintings opposed to paintings of cars and shells, she is clearly off the mark.Irritatingly, in books like these, Michel Foucault is never far away. When two neigbours in a neighbourhood of merchants have an informal chat about the price of tulips at their doorstep, in Goldgar's words they strenghten hierarchies of knowledge within constrained physical, cultural and commercial boundaries. And when these people go to the baker to buy a loaf of bread and discuss flowers over there, the customer, the baker *and* the bakery all may be identified as (being in the centre of) nodes of information.As for the historical narrative, despite all the insights of Tulipmania, I thought many themes were left ill explored.
Tulipmania: Money, Honor, and Knowledge in the Dutch Golden Age Ik hou van delen (dutch childrens books, kinderboeken, dutch kids books, nederlandse boeken, children's books in dutch, dutch baby book) (Dutch Bedtime Collection) (Dutch Edition) Dutch Oven Cooking: 30 Mouthwatering Dutch Oven, One Pot Recipes for Quick and Easy Campfire Meals (UPDATED) (Dutch Oven & Camp Cooking) The Dutch Oven Cookbook: 25 Delicious Dutch Oven Recipes for your Dutch Oven The Embarrassment of Riches: An Interpretation of Dutch Culture in the Golden Age Codigo De Honor/ Code of Honor: Conferencia 4 (Spanish Edition) W.E.B. Griffin Series Reading Order: Series List - In Order: Presidential Agent series, Badge of Honor series, The Corps series, Honor Bound series, Brotherhood ... (Listastik Series Reading Order Book 14) Organising Knowledge: Taxonomies, Knowledge and Organisational Effectiveness (Chandos Knowledge Management) Cast Iron and Dutch Oven Cookbook Box Set (2 in 1): Over 60 Easy and Delicious Paleo Recipes Using Cast Iron Skillet and Dutch Oven (Crock Pot & Dump Dinner) Dutch Oven, Cast Iron and Stir-Fry Box Set (5 in 1): Easy and Delicious Dutch Oven, Flat Belly Cast Iron, Paleo, Wok Recipes (Creative Recipes & Camp Meals) One-Pot Dump Dinners: Low Carb Soups, Dinners and Healthy Desserts for Your Dutch Oven with No-Mess and No-Stress (Dutch Oven & One Pot Cooking) Dutch oven: Dutch Oven Recipes for Amazing and Easy Meals Dutch Oven Dining: 60 Simple & #Delish Dutch Oven Recipes for the Great Outdoors (60 Super Recipes Book 24) I'm in Dutch!: A Laugh Out Loud Guide to Dutch oven Cooking. The Ultimate Dutch Oven Cookbook: 25 Marvelous Dutch Oven Cooking Recipes for all Types of Cooks Dutch Oven Magic: An Easy to Follow Cookbook for Delicious Dutch Oven Recipes (Outdoor Cooking 2) Sports Betting: The Secret System to Success and Make Money (Win Money Betting System) (Sports Betting, Make Money, Betting Strategy) Debt-Free: How to Get Out of Debt To Your Road Towards Financial Freedom (Get Out of Debt, Budgeting Money, Save Money, Credit Card Debt, Wealth Management, Credit Control, Money Tips) Energy and power: How man uses animals, wind, water, heat, electricity, chemistry, and atoms to help him in his daily living (Golden library of knowledge) Everything I Need To Know I Learned From a Little Golden Book (Little Golden Books (Random House))